The most expensive mistake a commercial seller makes happens before the property is listed: signing with the broker who named the biggest number. I am a broker too, so hold my answers to the same questions. This is not legal advice. Have an attorney read any listing agreement before you sign it.
Why a single number deserves suspicion
Recorded South Florida sales since 2023 show how much price per square foot moves with size alone. Buildings under 7,500 SF have a median near $314 per foot in industrial, $468 in office and $496 in retail. Buildings over 25,000 SF sit near $221, $224 and $266. A broker who quotes one confident figure without saying which kind of building it was built from is guessing. The honest version is a range with a reason attached. You can see real ranges by city in the sold price range tool.
Eight things to watch for
1. A number with no comps behind it. "Similar buildings" is not evidence. Ask for addresses, closing dates, square footage and prices. Then ask why those and not others.
2. A number before the questions. A broker who names a value before seeing your leases, expirations and condition is quoting a hope. The first meeting should be mostly them asking.
3. The highest number in the room. Pitching three brokers and listing with the highest is how an overpriced listing happens. The building sits, buyers learn the asking price is soft, and the cut comes anyway. Ask each broker how they reached the figure. The best answer is rarely the biggest one.
4. A long exclusive with no way out. Read the term, the termination rights, and the tail, the period after expiry in which you still owe a commission if a buyer the broker introduced closes. A short term with a renewal option is easier to leave than a long one. Your attorney should negotiate this, not you.
5. Fees you find in the agreement. Commission is the obvious one. Ask about marketing charges, retainers, administrative fees, and any cooperating-broker split. Get the total cost at three different sale prices, in writing, before you sign.
6. A conflict nobody mentioned. If the firm can also represent the buyer, or has its own buyer in mind, ask how that conflict is handled and get the answer in writing. Whether a disclosure is required depends on the facts, so ask your attorney.
7. A marketing plan with no specifics. "We'll market it everywhere" means nothing. Which buyer types, which lists, how many calls a week, and what happens at day 30 if nothing comes in? If the answers are vague, the work will be too.
8. No mention of your taxes. A sale can trigger depreciation recapture and capital gains. A 1031 exchange has hard deadlines. A good broker says "talk to your CPA before you list." One who skips it has not thought about what you keep.
Questions to ask any broker, including me
- What is the range, and what is it based on? How many sales, how recent?
- What can your comps not tell us about my building?
- How long is the agreement, how do I end it early, and what is the tail?
- What will it cost me in total at three different prices?
- Who could end up on the other side of this deal, and how is that conflict handled?
- What happens on day 30 if there is no offer?
- Why should I sell now, and what would make you tell me not to?
That last one matters most. If you do not need to sell, the right answer is sometimes "don't." The seller page covers the reasons owners sell. To see what comparable buildings recorded, start with sold property by market or ask for a broker opinion of value and judge it against the questions above.
Frequently asked questions
Should I list at the highest number a broker gives me?
Not by itself. The highest number is often the broker's way of winning the listing, not a read on what buyers will pay. Ask how each figure was built and listen for comps with addresses and dates.
How long should a commercial listing agreement run?
There is no standard answer. A shorter term with a renewal option is easier to exit if the broker is not delivering. Have an attorney review the term, termination rights and tail period before you sign.
Do I need a broker opinion of value before I list?
It helps to have a range and a reason before you decide whether to sell at all. A BOV is not an appraisal, and a lender or court may require one. Ask for the method and the comps behind it.